top of page

Jenkins' Personal View of Jesus

3 days ago
6 min read

Is Jenkins Ironically Repeating History?

For all his protest against “statues” and “stained glass windows"--those visual depictions of Jesus handed to the illiterate masses, who were intentionally denied access to the truth of God’s Word--Jenkins is perpetuating the fallacy of Catholicism:  that Jesus can be found outside of Scripture within visual representations of Him. 

In addition to religious art and iconography, which all too often did create and perpetuate pagan idolatry, Catholicism also embraced religious drama as a replacement for firsthand knowledge of the Scriptures.  If you read the medieval mystery play known as Noah’s Flood, or the Chester Noah Play, you will find a humorous portrayal of Noah’s wife as a rebellious hussy, a stereotype nowhere to be found in Scripture.  You will find in cycles of these medieval mystery or miracle plays any number of completely fictitious and humorous elements that, ironically, would seem to contradict, rather than to reinforce, other more sedate and dignified two-or-three-dimensional artistic portrayals of Scripture. 

Therefore, not only were medieval conceptions of Scripture primarily unscriptural; they were by no means always formal or stiff.  But what Jenkins has in common with the Catholic tradition of times past is his assumption that he can substitute his fiction for Scripture to “help” the Biblically illiterate masses, and that he can do so without damage to the truth—all while intentionally controlling his viewers’ conceptions of Jesus.  This matter of control is the all-too-often unsaid and unchallenged motivation of revolutionaries, if not of wolves in sheep's clothing. For all the supposed extra knowledge gained by sampling the serpent’s forbidden fruit, the deceived lose their knowledge of truth.  We see this playing out in Jenkins’ show. 


Who Is Jenkins' Stereotypical Jesus?

Jenkins has created another Jesus, but this isn't a new Jesus. Jenkins has succeeded only in throwing statues and stained glass windows into the fire to shape his own golden calf. One stereotype has replaced another. In running from the "stereotypes" fed from script-based shows and historic Christianity, Jenkins has succeeded in capturing the Jesus of contemporary culture. And the ironic result is that you can find this Jesus everywhere--if not in statues or stained glass windows, then in woke agendas, progressive Christianity, the prosperity gospel, and hyper-grace--everywhere, that is, except in Scripture.

Even if The Chosen fans do consult the Gospels, their minds have already been stained with the likeness of Jenkins' own art. It doesn't matter that Jenkins didn't chisel statues or solder colored glass into a window; his stereotyped Jesus is every bit an idol, and this fact is self-evident from the unthinking worship of his fans.

One of the most sobering realities of Scripture is the fact that deception almost never works in reverse. More often than not, the darkness only deepens in those who do not even know they are deceived. When once we deviate from Scripture, we don't get to dictate the results. Therefore, by sidestepping the authority of truth, Jenkins has arguably deconstructed his own show. 


What are the Consequences of this Stereotype?

The popularity of The Chosen series alone will do one of two things: it will place in the category of "stereotype" any presentation of Jesus that does not jive with The Chosen, or it will live up to the self-fulfilling prophecy of finding the "Jesus" of The Chosen in the Gospels themselves--even though he isn't there.

This has already happened among Jenkins' fans. On the one hand, we hear that many of them have begun reading the Bible for the first time, but, on the other, we don't hear anything about them comparing the Bible with The Chosen. On the contrary, we hear the overwhelming theme that The Chosen never contradicts Scripture. But that just simply is not so. So, if Jenkins' fans are now truly reading the Bible as he professes to have instructed them, how are they not turning away from The Chosen to detect how Jenkins has misled them? But they aren't. Every time someone tries to contend that the show is inaccurate or unbiblical, fans argue that it isn't and yet demand further proof that it is, having already denied the truth previously presented.

In their own way, these fans are technically "correct" since, with Jenkins' episodes being almost entirely fictitious, no one can say they "didn't happen." If no one knows whether or not they "didn't happen," how can these fictional episodes contradict Scripture? But the point is that Jenkins' scenes wouldn't have happened because the Jesus of the Gospels isn't "like that."

The "how do you know" rebuttal is an appeal to ignorance with an implied dare of proving Jenkins' added scenes false. This fallacy is a favorite among Jenkins' fans and is an obvious reason our Lord forbad us to add to the Scriptures. The prevailing "Oh, The Chosen doesn't claim to be Scripture" rebuttal is also a fallacy, since the show most certainly does intend to shape its viewers' understanding of Jesus--a true understanding of Whom is not possible apart from Scripture.

It seems self-evident that nothing fictitious is true, no matter how tightly we squeeze our eyelids shut to imagine that it is. Do you want an understanding of Jesus "enlightened" by 5% factual material floating in 95% fiction, or one informed by 100% factual accuracy with 0% fiction, and that from eyewitness accounts as applied by the Holy Spirit?

But Jenkins' audience doesn't understand these distinctions, and it is Jenkins' appeal to his audience's ignorance that fuels their own appeal to ignorance. It isn't necessary to rebut their "how do you know" fallacy on theological grounds. Even an honest secular critic could prove by literary analysis alone that Jenkins' Jesus and the biblical Jesus are two entirely different characters.

Their traits and motivations are not only separate but also contradictory, and even where they appear to overlap, they do not. Jenkins' Jesus is a flat character, for all his added and supposedly scintillating qualities, and if anything, this "flatness" has resulted from skewing Christ's human traits at the expense of His Deity. Therefore, the hypnotic dance between circular reasoning and the appeal to ignorance can be rebutted by any high school debate team trained to detect fallacies and by anyone trained to critique literature.


What is Jenkins' Personal View of Jesus?

One of the most sobering questions of all is whether Jenkins himself has been deceived as to who Jesus really is. When we examine his own remarks about Jesus, our questions begin circling like hawks. Recently, I was deeply disturbed to hear Jenkins' statement regarding Charlie Kirk's assassination in which he said that our biggest concern was how to answer the question, "Who do you belong to?" This he "answered" for himself--but only in a manner of speaking.

Hesitating first, he fumbled, "Um and I belong to and claim um [he looks away as if searching for words] possession by the Creator of the universe, um by the God of the universe and His Son Jesus who uh is also part of the Godhead who came to earth as a human being and taught us not only in His humanity but in His divinity what it means to be holy and what it means to pursue righteousness even if we'll never get there on this side of eternity."

There is enough good here to camouflage what is really dangerous here. Jenkins mentions Jesus as a teacher but not as our Savior, and he refers to Jesus as "also part of the Godhead," as if the three Persons of the Trinity are "parts" and as if Jesus is just one part rather than fully God. Jenkins' word salad is almost as bad as some politicians'.

I just plugged some of Jenkins' words into Google and identified his statement about Jesus being "also part of the Godhead" as the heresy of Arianism. The words "also" and "part" are minimizing, as if Jesus isn't fully God--which would please Jenkins' Mormon friends, Muslims, and others in his widely ecumenical and unchurched audience. At best, Jenkins' response is notoriously vague for someone creating a multi-season show about the "authentic" Jesus.

In these times of Oneness Pentecostalism, modalism, and who-knows-what-ism, it is imperative that we state clearly who Jesus is. For that matter, I found it strange that Jenkins had to grope for words when referring first to the "Creator of the universe" instead of coming right out and boldly saying that he belongs to the Lord Jesus Christ. Christ purchased our souls if we trust in Him, and our first reaction should be to honor Him as our Lord.

It is not as if Jenkins was standing before a panel of atheists. He was being interviewed by Billy Hallowell on CBN. If he can't get it right here, will he stand up for Jesus anywhere? If even Jenkins doesn't really know who Jesus is--or doesn't know what he believes about Jesus--then he is wasting his time telling the rest of us we need to break our stereotypes of statues and stained glass windows.


Comments


© 2024 by by Carolyn Joy. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page